Is Hiring A Private College Counselor Worth It?

If you are in your last years of high school, the college admissions process is likely on your mind. You have probably met with your school guidance counselor and you may have started doing some research yourself, but there is so much information out there so it is easy to feel overwhelmed. You might be unsure about where to apply and how to go about the application process. This is where college counseling can make a big difference. People who have extensive experience with the college application process can help you with your own journey. With expert guidance, you can get help with everything from choosing the right schools, to writing a successful Common App essay, and even navigating financial aid. So what are your options with college counseling?

The first option is to seek help from your high school guidance counselor. One of their jobs is to help students figure out their path in the future and guide them through the college application process. If you are looking for a completely free and accessible option, this may be the right one for you. However, the main problem with this option is that guidance counselors have a lot on their plates. They also can have hundreds of students at once, so they will not be able to dedicate a lot of time to your own college application. You will have to do a lot of the work on your own. The help you can get from guidance counselors is very limited, so many high school students only use this resource as a supplement rather than as a primary source.

Another option is online college counseling services. Depending on the website, the prices can range from affordable to expensive. These websites come with a lot of flexibility, as they offer multiple packages based on your individual needs. You can access it from anywhere, as it is completely virtual. However, there is less of a personal interaction with these services, and the quality of help you receive can vary depending on who is helping you, and how qualified they are.

For more low-income or underprivileged families, there are numerous non-profit organizations that provide free or low-cost college counseling services. For those seeking a very affordable option that is better than a guidance counselor, this may be the right fit for you. However, they are often in high demand and have limited resources, so the amount of support you can get with these services may be restricted.

The final option for college counseling is hiring private college counselors. We will explore this option in the next few sections. If you are debating whether hiring a private college counselor is the right move for you, keep reading to discover some pros and cons of private counseling!

Con #1: Expensive
Private college counselors are VERY expensive! While the work they do to further your application is oftentimes very beneficial, their work also costs you and your family thousands of dollars, which can be a major barrier for many families. While the alternative options often come with fewer resources and poorer quality, they can still help you achieve all your college goals without all of the expenses.
‍
Con #2: Inequities
Since private college counseling is so expensive, the majority of families with students applying to colleges can’t afford them, and the ones that can afford them are put at an advantage. This widens the gap between those who have access to premium services and those who don’t, increasing inequalities in education.
‍
Con #3: No guarantees
While hiring a private college counselor is extremely helpful, there is never a guarantee that you will get the results you want, which may make you feel that all of that money went to waste. At the end of the day, college acceptance can be unpredictable, and no amount of money can ensure that you will get into your top choice schools. Also, there is no guarantee that you will receive a private college counselor you are satisfied with. There are some counselors that you may not connect well with, or that may push certain choices on you based on their own beliefs since the process is so extensive, which limits your freedom to truly make your own decisions in the journey. Consider all of these cons when deciding if the investment is worth it.

At the end of the day, it’s a gamble. Whether you have a private college counselor or a more affordable source to help you through the process, neither can provide you with the guarantee that you will get exactly what you want in the college admissions process. That’s why it’s crucial to carefully think about the pros and cons and discuss them with your family. Depending on the kind of support you are looking for, private college counseling can possibly be worth all of the expenses, but there are plenty of more affordable options that can provide great guidance. Decide exactly what you are looking for with college counseling, and think about whether it is worth paying the price. Do some research to figure out what all of your options are, just how expensive they are, and how helpful they can each be in your college admissions process. And remember that if you come to the conclusion that private college counselors are too expensive and not worth it for you and your family, there are plenty of other options out there for you that can provide you with quality counseling. No matter what path you choose, you got this!